Grumpy Bird Reviews: Captain America The Winter Soldier

I finally got around to seeing the latest Captain America. The first one was firmly average. How about part two? Is the Grumpy Bird still grumpy?


Captain-America-The-Winter-Soldier-IMAX-PosterCaptain America The Winter Soldier

Dir: Anthony & Joe Russo

Screenwriters: Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely


I’m struggling here. So much of what I have to say about various properties has been negative. I heard a lot of great things about CA:WS that I thought the only reaction was to be let down. No movie is perfect. But I have to say that this might be the best superhero movie that has come out. I went in cautiously optimistic and left the theater wanting to watch it all over again. Just to get them out of the way here are a few of the nit-picky things I think could have been handled better.

(Currently Spoiler free)

  • The middle of the movie dragged a little. Not much. But in the height of tension there felt like there was a touch of meandering.
  • It could have used a little more Falcon. Anthony Mackie was great. He had some nice moments. More would be better.
  • There was, ummm…. I’m sure there was a third thing. Hmmm…

Now, here are some of the things I liked. Again, going to be spoiler free so expect vague-ness.


The action in this movie was really well handled. Very well choreographed. Flashy but still seemed practical. Every time Winter Soldier tossed that knife around it felt like there was a purpose. So many action movies just feel like fast cuts that make it impossible to follow the flow of the movies. This held onto scenes a little longer. They want the audience to appreciate the action choreography. Compare the opening fight between Batroc (and the nerd in me just shouted for joy at being able to bring up Batroc as a positive in a major motion picture) and Cap to another superhero fight between Batman and Bane. One of these fights was a boring collection of clumsy face punches and one was an inventive combat that pitted two highly skilled fighters against each other. Decide which is which for yourselves. (Hint: the bad fights were in Dark Knight Rises.) I never got bored with the action sequences.

But this movie just wasn’t action. The story and actors brought their A game. Cap visiting Peggy Carter in the hospital. If you did not have a swell of emotion during that scene, I don’t know what it takes to move you. That look of pain in Cap’s eyes when she recognizes him again. Man. Natasha talking about her past. It is just tiny little moments, but it does so much to humanize her and enhance the character. They have done more with the Black Widow in this film than in the other movies combined.

I love that it wasn’t just a superhero flick. It was a spy flick. it was about good old fashioned espionage. Some of the superhero movies we’ve all seen use that classification as a limitation, or an excuse for campy scenes or nonsensical villainous plots (Magneto turning everyone into mutants, the Lizard turning everyone into Lizards, Liam Neeson crashing a train, etc.) The plot here makes perfect sense with the stated goals of the villains. Hurrah.

But even while it was a spy flick, it kept hold of the fact that it is a superhero movie. Captain America the Winter Soldier is not ashamed that it is a superhero story. Batman, Superman, these movies have always slightly shied away from their comic book origins. CA:WS loves that it is a comic book. Metal arms. Flying Wing pack. Cap’s Shield. Zola. It takes all of those fantastical elements and holds them up to be seen as awesome.

There is one other thing I appreciated: this is not a cheesecake movie. Like most movies the main and supporting cast are incredibly attractive. Incredibly. Just wow. And, they come from a medium (comics) that has made a lot of money by showcasing the more titillating aspects of its characters. I came away from this movie really admiring the restraint shown in not having Chris Evans, Scarlett Johansson and Anthony Mackie uncovered as much as possible. The most it gives is a few scenes of the character in undershirts. Bravo.

Overall this movie was awesome. I do think it is going to be my favorite Superhero film. It was great action, great character moments and a lot of heart. Go see it.

3 thoughts on “Grumpy Bird Reviews: Captain America The Winter Soldier

  1. I did finally get to see Captain America: Winter Soldier, and really enjoyed it. There’s something about being a non American and watching a movie about Cap, which I think they got right. He still feels like a hero everyone can get behind.

    I don’t know if it’s my favourite Marvel movie of all time. Despite its problems, the Edward Norton Hulk movie just impresses me more and more each time I watch it. One of those problems, which, as you mentioned, CA:WS got right, was the mostly random inclusion of Bruce’s love interest in the early parts of the movie.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s